Intangible Partners
Why manufacturing execution breaks down
PDF
01 The Tension Systems exist. Execution still breaks down.

They bought the system. But the gap stayed.

Small to mid-market manufacturers have invested in the systems they were told would close the gap between the production plan and what actually happens on the floor. Most of those systems are still running. The gap is still there, and it has its own infrastructure now: spreadsheets, email threads, the supervisor's voice notes, and what the second shift lead happens to remember.

A small to mid-market plant runs two stacks at once
The system stack
ERP86%
Production scheduling64%
WMS55%
MES38%
The gap
The workaround stack
Spreadsheets76%
Email and chat·
Hallway, voice notes·
Tribal knowledge·
What the plan says, against what the floor knows. Adoption among small and mid-market plants surveyed (n = 235).

The ERP is right about the plan. The spreadsheet is right about the day. Nothing connects them in real time.

What the system said we had did not match what was actually available on the floor. Plant manager / GM, Southeast U.S., $25M to $100M plant
The bottom line

The factory is software enabled, but execution is not execution aware. The cost lives in that gap.